The early acclaimed reception and fresh Rotten Tomatoes score for Blue Beetle are sadly not enough to get audiences’ expectations up for DC Studios’ first character, introduced as part of James Gunn‘s Gods and Monsters universe. The Xolo Maridueña starrer DCU film has landed a B+ CinemaScore leaving fans dismayed while detractors are blaming WBD’s lack of marketing & the comic book movie genre as a whole for releasing generic titles.
DC’s first Latino superhero flick is not off to a great start being compared to the likes of Shazam! Fury of the Gods and Thor: Love and Thunder – the lukewarm entries of 2023’s comic book movies. But some of the Blue Beetle Battalion stans seem to have anticipated the low cinema score by relating it to the weak opening weekend estimates.
The DCU feature earned a meager $3.3 million domestically from Thursday preview shows and is expected to pull $25-32M from the first three-day earnings. DC Studios’ previous entries The Flash and Shazam 2’s opening earnings are slightly above and were praised by critics and fans alike. However, Blue Beetle also shares similarities with the last two titles in failing to interest general audiences.
As box office reporter Luiz Fernando noted, Blue Beetle’s CinemaScore is on par with Wonder Woman 1984, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, Black Adam and James Gunn’s The Suicide Squad. Out of the aforementioned titles, only Doctor Strange 2 and Dwayne Johnson starrer DC film earned the big buck at the global box office.
Audiences have spoken!!! #2
Another day, another B+ for a CBM Post-Covid, & specially for #DCEU, as #BlueBeetle received a B+ #CinemaScore from moviegoers, on par with #ShazamFuryOfTheGods, #MultiverseOfMadness, #BlackAdam, #ThorLoveAndThunder, #WW84 & #TheSuicideSquad!
1/ pic.twitter.com/KclrFYActl— Luiz Fernando (@Luiz_Fernando_J) August 19, 2023
Being on par with WW84 and Thor L&T is an insult https://t.co/SglMLVDU7v
— Discussing Superman (@SupermanEnjoyer) August 19, 2023
I believe Cinemascore and Rotten Tomatoes have absolutely fucked up people's ideas about movies. People whine about fandom content, but if anything has devalued thoughtful movie criticism, it's crap like this. It was all downhill after it became more than two thumbs up or down. https://t.co/62rJOsfYsG
— Joshua M. Patton (@JoshuaMPatton) August 19, 2023
The CinemaScore is “on par with Black Adam (and) Thor: Love and Thunder”… 💀 https://t.co/yBhzhpvSKV
— CanWeGetSomeToast (@CanWeGetToast) August 19, 2023
Neb be like "Mind you, we are in the pandemic" https://t.co/NUEZn1jA9j
— Marc (@MarAbh999) August 19, 2023
I’m so over this bullshit https://t.co/Dg6S4mF5N6
— The Moonlight Warrior 🌙 (@BlackMajikMan90) August 19, 2023
Not even an A-? Damn it’s joeover for this movie bro 😭😭if you’re wondering a B+ for a CBM is not good. Shazam 2 ironically also got a B+ lol https://t.co/w0RU0DqJ1P
— Toon talks (@toontalks2456) August 19, 2023
This one doesn’t make sense to me. https://t.co/6jCBlBEarY
— RJ (@ResonantJustice) August 19, 2023
While Black Adam’s earnings still bring up the debate over if the film falls under the profitable bracket or a loss for Warner Bros. Pictures – it still launched with a $143M global opening. Multiverse of Madness is the highest-earning title from MCU in 2023 with a $185M debut and a global run of $955M.
Other films with a B+ CinemaScore include Love and Thunder which is the second worst-rated score from Marvel Studios with Ant-man and the Wasp: Quantumania topping the list with B. Though in fairness, Blue Beetles pales in comparison to the marketing efforts that went in for the above-mentioned DC & Marvel title.
Disappointment among fans is at an all-time high but the Blue Beetle Battalion gang is hoping to amplify its social media reach to increase its performance in the following weeks of its theatrical run. With a $104M production budget, as revealed by its director Ángel Manuel Soto – there is hope for the film to either break even or turn profitable for studios and exhibitors. The Flash‘s BO failure is already estimated to have led to a $260M massive loss for WBD.
On the bright side of the conversation, some critics and fans noted that Blue Beetle has earned more than what the studio would’ve originally anticipated since it was a direct-to-streaming title for HBO Max. In any case, although a sequel for Blue Beetle may be tied down to the BO report – the character’s return has been assured by DCU chief James Gunn.
If this site considers a B + not good by any means. They need to revisit grade school 🤣 https://t.co/IfI94GRjhm
— SSJ K-DOT (@SsjKDot18) August 19, 2023
Dude…🫠 https://t.co/OeWRjSoSch
— Chris Wong-Swenson⚡ (@pingpongflix) August 19, 2023
Blue Beetle Battalion we have to mobilize. https://t.co/gvTARtqtYs
— JJ (@WildeePatrol) August 19, 2023
this movie was way better than shazam 2 and black adam https://t.co/ydDtOMT4YM
— Mania💫 Saw & Loved Blue Beetle (@NovaMania17) August 19, 2023
Might have good legs, but the domestic opening weekend won't be pretty. https://t.co/ztAWiszH39
— RogueCreed (@RogueCreed) August 19, 2023
It ain't easy man https://t.co/xQUal1EDLq pic.twitter.com/jq7cIxBzLW
— Reza (@Reza_shuaib) August 19, 2023
DC’s cinema scores make zero sense
Suicide Squad: B+
Justice League: B+
Birds of Prey: B+
Wonder Woman 1984: B+
The Suicide Squad: B+
Black Adam: B+
Shazam 2: B+Blue Beetle is better than every movie on this list except TSS https://t.co/RaFQlssA94
— BLUE BEETLE OUT NOW (@blnebeetle) August 19, 2023
I’m not entirely shocked because it’s a origin story and fans at this point have seen a billion of them (thanks marvel).
Again the cast does a great job and Blue Beetle will return so I’m good overall. The best Blue Beetle storyline hasn’t even been told yet and that’ll be fun https://t.co/vdXJZOw6xc
— Colin Alger (@colin_alger1) August 19, 2023
If Multiverse Of Madness is getting the same score as Thor Love And Thunder, then the people over at Cinemascore need to be checked big time. https://t.co/k5y0Vvospj
— ☬ 𝕬𝖋𝖔𝖑𝖆𝖇𝖎 𝕻𝖆𝖚𝖑 ☬ (@Pauliyed_) August 19, 2023
As of this writing, Blue Beetle has a 76% Tomatometer certified fresh out of 165 reviews. But the audience score stands at 92% though it is subject to change as more verified ratings pour in the following days.
Blue Beetle is currently in theaters.