HBO’s plan to capture the Euphoria magic in the Abel “The Weeknd” Tesfaye starrer series, The Idol, seems to have hit a snag after being labeled as “Torture Porn” in a scathing Rolling Stone piece. Co-creator Sam Levinson has particularly been highlighted for reportedly reshooting the whole season – with his version featuring explicit sexual and physical abuse centered around disturbing sequences between Lily-Rose Depp‘s Jocelyn and Tesfaye’s Tedros.
The Idol series has had Euphoria fans’ interest piqued ever since the teaser clips showcased a racy and enticing adaptation of a pop idol’s life in the music industry. The star-studded cast like BLACKPINK’s Jennie and the titular star Tesfaye and Depp have been the selling point of the show, in fact, The Idol was being positioned to take the Sunday schedule for HBO, in absence of the hit Game of Thrones spin-off, House of the Dragon.
Unfortunately, reports detailing a mess involving rewrites and reshoots on The Idol production have scarred the show before its premiere. The series centers over Depp’s Jocelyn as a struggling Pop Idol trying to reclaim her title as the sexiest Pop star in America which kicks off by getting herself into a roller-coaster of a relationship with Tesfaye’s character – Tedros, a LA nightclub owner and cult leader.
Jennie stans call out The Idol creators for reducing her character’s screentime
Some TV fans have resorted to criticizing HBO’s decision to bring Levinson which erased the original plot directed under Amy Seimetz. The Weeknd also faces pushback for allegedly being the driving force behind its changes as the co-creator and shifting the series in a different direction as it leans too much into a “female perspective”. But in the latest follow-up report by TMZ, that claim was dismissed as “he doesn’t feel that way at all”. In addition, TMZ’s story also states that The Weeknd sees Levinsen’s changes as a success although it features edgy elements.
After The Weeknd’s latest mocking response to the Pop Culture magazine through a clip from the series, his fanbase’s support has amplified. But it hasn’t stopped Blackpink stans from sharing their distaste for The Idol since the RS article claims that Jennie’s role has been reduced to “like three or four lines per episode”. Apparently, the rewrites have made her character’s arc insignificant to the larger story.
Many were disappointed to learn Jennie’s debut performance was rather just being used as a marketing push for the series. As one production source told Stone, “Her job was to sit there [and] look pretty, basically.” Readers can check out the reactions below.
.@RollingStone did we upset you? pic.twitter.com/Uyx06lyRgx
— The Weeknd (@theweeknd) March 1, 2023
The Weeknd reading The Idol script and seeing too many lines for women pic.twitter.com/c35XTW7G9V
— 𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐲 𝐭𝐚𝐲𝐥𝐨𝐫 (@treytylor) March 1, 2023
so basically jennie gave the idol ALL the hype and this is how they decided to treat her…? pic.twitter.com/9I7kU1bpa4
— ︎ines (@lovesicckgirls) March 1, 2023
That RS story about The Idol is really damning, but how come HBO keeps doing this stuff?? This ($$$ vanity sexist fantasy music fame narrative w/ marquee creators out of control) is how we got the awful Vinyl
— Emily Nussbaum (@emilynussbaum) March 2, 2023
My take: Don't screw up and disrespect Jennie with her The Idol role. Not only does she literally live the idol world more than any castmember as a K-pop idol but the representation she brings is important and can create significant opportunities for more diversity in Hollywood
— Jeff Benjamin (@Jeff__Benjamin) March 1, 2023
if you're mad about the whole thing with The Idol and Sam Levison I recommend watching Sun Don't Shine and She Dies Tomorrow, both directed by The Idol's original creator Amy Seimetz pic.twitter.com/zrPaQ8Krpq
— alison rumfitt (parody) (@hangsawoman) March 1, 2023
Rolling Stone: we’ve uncovered scripts and sources on The Idol being a violent r@pe fantasy with misogynistic shock value
The Weeknd: you’re just pressed our pro-r@pe show called you irrelevant 😏💅
— chateau bunny ❄️ (@cocainecross) March 1, 2023
Me when I find The Weeknd after finding out what he did with The Idol pic.twitter.com/bu15jEojHH
— guy1853 (@guy1853) March 2, 2023
ykw im not focusing on the idol anymore and will only tune in for the jennie clips provided by jnkloops. pinkchella and jisoo’s solo almost around the corner baby we got bigger fish to fry pic.twitter.com/5HXMfedSeO
— ً (@pinksgroove) March 1, 2023
“sources from the idol production team say that sam levison was writing basically a rape fantasy”
you: u mad bro???
— roslyn (@roslyntalusan) March 1, 2023
Media literacy is dead, “The Idol” Rolling Stone article is not marketing for the show it’s an actual report on the failings of the production. Abel’s response is out of touch. Not taking this seriously is how people like Joss Whedon run rampant through Hollywood unchecked.
— Daric L. Cottingham, M.A. (@DaricCott) March 1, 2023
Watch them end up cancelling the idol ✋😹pic.twitter.com/qxLQFWhKWw
— 😹 (fan account) (@arixabeI) March 1, 2023
the cast and crew after The Idol wrapped filming pic.twitter.com/PmlToSG8Qk
— EM 🪷 (@uhhmmily) March 1, 2023
the idol would’ve been out w the original plot if sam didn’t touch SHIT pic.twitter.com/DRzxuenfel
— 𝓁𝒾𝓎𝒶𝒽 ◆ (@herdarkesthourz) March 1, 2023
i was so excited for the idol and now its just… disappointment after disappointment. im convinced that men are the root cause of every problem 😐 pic.twitter.com/WQmuwd0K1I
— jj ⚘ (@chaelisagrande) March 1, 2023
was only watching the idol for her & since she’s barely in it this will do pic.twitter.com/q9zyEQRDmW
— ᴋ. (@korysstorm) March 1, 2023
just remembered that rachel sennott is in the idol… pic.twitter.com/CHmy6f8nSW
— lex (@gretagerwigflew) March 1, 2023
The irony about “The Idol” is that Seimetz's direction of the series was the better, more compelling story. It should have stuck with telling the story through the “female perspective” like it was initially going to, especially so far into production. Just bleeding funds now.
— Daric L. Cottingham, M.A. (@DaricCott) March 1, 2023
The Weeknd shifted The Idol from a cult show to a rape fantasy centring himself. With the help of fellow creep Sam Levinson.
Seriously, just cancel this over-budget, over-written piece of garbage. https://t.co/6oGeG3TYE3 pic.twitter.com/5SDhwzRwOP
— Riri Rites (@RiriRites) March 1, 2023
The Rumor floating around that The Weeknd felt the OG Version of The Idol was too focused on female perspective isn’t true. according to TMZ. pic.twitter.com/6SAXCMqL06
— THE IDOL HUB (@TheIdolHub) March 1, 2023
not jennie being click bait in the idol like zendaya in dune pic.twitter.com/E66jRGeoo2
— andriana シ (@MUGLERMIND) March 1, 2023
HBO for its part has stood by the creators stating creative changes were made in the best interest of “both the production and the cast and crew” while assuring it was a safe and collaborative working environment.
The scrapping of the original version has reportedly led to a loss of over $75 million for HBO, at a time when its parent company is prioritizing cost-cutting to keep business afloat through unprecedented actions like the Batgirl cancellation. The Idol does not have a release date attached yet.