DCU’s Gods and Monsters has found its Superman in David Corenswet but the internet is more surprised over The Politician star’s resemblance with Henry Cavill. James Gunn has confirmed the casting for Superman: Legacy which also includes Rachel Brosnahan hired to play Lois Lane but Emma Mackey supporters are disappointed since the Sex Education actor was on the final shortlist during the screen test and was apparently a close call.
An audition for Superman: Legacy that began as early as April whilst James Gunn was also simultaneously on the Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 press tour has finally concluded. With WBD CEO David Zaslav also signing off on the new Superman – the DC Studios CEO addressed THR‘s report on David Corenswet taking over the Man of Steel role from Superman and Rachel Brosnahan from Amy Adams on Twitter. “Accurate! (They are not only both incredible actors, but also wonderful people).”
Since the start of the screen test, David Corenswet’s casting as Superman was approved by the masses on social media for his charming Clark Kent persona. But many have also pointed out Corenswet looks like Henry Cavill or a rather younger-looking version of Zack Snyder’s Justice League star.
It, unfortunately, has also received criticism for casting a Cavill lookalike rather than offering a continuation of the Snydeverse character after his faceless cameo in The Flash. But a few Superman fans have pushed back to state Henry also shared similarities to Christopher Reeves, Tom Welling and Brandon Routh – the previous live-action iterations of the Man of Steel.
"David Corenswet just looks like Henry Cavill"
Yeah that's true but Henry Cavill looks like Brandon Routh who looks like Tom Welling who looks like Christopher Reeve who looks like…you guys aren't gonna believe this
— J.C is seeing Fall Out Boy (@thejcelliott) June 27, 2023
Wow. I can’t believe a Superman actor looks like another Superman actor who look just like the Superman from the comics. Y’all need to go out & get some air & find love. https://t.co/EwAY5ptLyy
— Jesabel (@JesabelRaay) June 28, 2023
Henry Cavill looking at David Corenswet after the Superman: Legacy announcement pic.twitter.com/lqHMz86aSz
— BLURAYANGEL 🦇 (@blurayangel) June 27, 2023
Not too surprised David got the role when he literally looks like a cloning facility fused the DNA of Henry Cavill & Tom Welling pic.twitter.com/zDxiQw7MOO
— Lunwi (@Lunwi88) June 27, 2023
"David Corenswet looks like Henry Cavill" ❌
"Both, Henry & David look like SUPERMAN" ✅🤝🏻 https://t.co/oPeDLqnS4q
— Moaz (@DarkMassacre26) June 27, 2023
David Corenswet is 6'4 and Rachel Brosnahan is 5'3. We are literally getting this in live action. pic.twitter.com/aLKFzy4sQk
— ClarkQuill97 (@CQuill97) June 27, 2023
It's so funny how ppl call Corenswet a Cavill copycat like its his fault that they look kinda similar
David pulled up the character creator menu when he was born for the sole purpose of stealing Henry's role as Superman
— Pェssmaker 🔆 (@Massive_Peace) June 27, 2023
Henry Cavill will forever be my Superman and although it hurts to say goodbye to him I’m so excited to see the torch get passed to David Corenswet as the new Man of Steel and the face of the DCU! pic.twitter.com/WDMV228ACz
— sabrina 🦇 (@nightwaynes) June 27, 2023
“🤬 DAVID CORENSWET LOOKS LIKE HENRY CAVILL WHY DIDN’T THEY KEEP HENRY CAVILL?!?!?!????!!!!!🤬” and who does Henry Cavill look like…? I’ll give you a hint: pic.twitter.com/2TCqysqfLK
— Philiam 🌴 (@pchidichimo3) June 28, 2023
We officially have a new Superman & Lois Lane in David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan!
They both look perfect for the part in James Gunn's upcoming Superman film
In fact David Corenswet looks like a baby Henry Cavill! pic.twitter.com/8O1uY6MWMq
— MissDeusGeek (@MissDeusGeek) June 27, 2023
If you don’t see the vision, then you must be blind.
“He is kindness in a world that thinks kindness is old-fashioned.” pic.twitter.com/iLdGgqliJw
— CanWeGetSomeToast (@CanWeGetToast) June 27, 2023
I'm sorry but David Corenswet looks nothing like Henry Cavill. Tom Brittney who also auditioned for Superman – he looks like Henry Cavill. To the point you'd think it was a deepfake pic.twitter.com/GFPMuSWoBL
— MH (@DapperSteve) June 27, 2023
David Corenswet as Superman looks good imo. Honest thoughts? pic.twitter.com/ZByTDJwyBD
— 𝗚𝗲𝗿𝗮𝗹𝘁 of North (@Itssan17) June 28, 2023
People keep saying that David looks like Henry, but both of them, along with Christopher Reeves, Tom Welling, Brandon, and others who have come before, LOOK like Superman. Y'all saying he a discount Henry Cavill is just dumb. pic.twitter.com/YtG3V6D71r
— DC Chambers (@dcu_chambers) June 28, 2023
A few fans felt Tom Brittney, who also auditioned for Superman: Legacy, looked more similar to Henry Cavill than Corenswet. Nonetheless, it’s fair to say both actors have the looks to portray DC’s red-caped superhero. Moreover, Above the Line‘s Jeff Sneider reports that Gunn himself had “no problem with that resemblance”.
Meanwhile, a small voice of criticism rose over casting 32-year-old Rachel Brosnahan as the Daily Planet reporter and romantic interest of Clark Kent as the 29-year-old Corenswet is younger than the actress. But that argument was shut down with a counterpoint that Amy Adams was 8 years older than Cavill.
There appears to be dismay over Emma Mackey losing the Lois Lane role but the actress’ fanbase is choosing to see the bright side of her career with an upcoming role in the anticipated Barbie. On the topic of Rachel, DCU stans are already comparing her to the comic adaptations calling her the “greatest Lois Lane casting ever”. Furthermore, when paired beside Corenswet – many noted the two look like the 1930s Action Comics era iteration.
The height difference between Corenswet and Brosnahan has led to some curious reactions from Superman fans. The Superman star is 6 feet 4 inches while is 5 feet 3 inches, a drastic difference. Similarly, Cavill is also 6 feet and 1 inch while Adams was 5 feet and 4 inches.
you mean to tell me that emma mackey didn’t get the role as lois lane,, pic.twitter.com/l8zD4L5R6H
— 🐢 (@anyavrse) June 27, 2023
emma mackey tried to save the dcu but james gunn wouldn’t let her pic.twitter.com/YzoCSTKMgC
— jules (@sinceiveknownu) June 27, 2023
David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan are the next Clark Kent/Superman and Lois Lane, respectively. This is absolutely great casting. SUPERMAN: LEGACY is off to a great start. They look plucked right from the 1930’s ACTION COMICS era. pic.twitter.com/k1Q70GzX5E
— Dan Marcus (@Danimalish) June 27, 2023
emma mackey you’ll always be my lois lane pic.twitter.com/58Kod2mMcm
— 🐢 (@anyavrse) June 27, 2023
To everybody who’s saying Rachel Brosnahan is “too old” to play Lois Lane since she’s three years older than David Corenswet, a) she’s only 32, shut the fuck up and b) Margot Kidder was four years older than Christopher Reeve in the original SUPERMAN so again, shut the fuck up pic.twitter.com/Uxbk2rG1k4
— Zoë Rose Bryant (@ZoeRoseBryant) June 27, 2023
this is the greatest lois lane casting ever like they COOKED i'm so happy pic.twitter.com/DuiTvnHLVl
— 🗡 (@taliasghul) June 27, 2023
emma mackey didn’t get lois lane pic.twitter.com/HKM6JZT2Cf
— hal (@halsmonteith) June 27, 2023
I know a lot of people were rooting for Emma Mackey (in the end she was my favourite too), but this really makes a ton of sense. Brosnahan is a fantastic actress and really screams Lois Lane. I’m very happy with this casting! #SupermanLegacy https://t.co/dNjdFNcZnh
— Finn (@_Broadlock_) June 27, 2023
Gunn better do Lois Lane justice!
Amy Adam's Lois was perfect in Man of Steel, finding out Superman's identity by investigating. A strong and smart woman.
Lois Lane is much more than just a love interest and it's important to make that relevant. I'm here for it! 😀 pic.twitter.com/G5UVSS93jT
— Z (@AMagicWriter) June 27, 2023
Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane was my biggest wish for Superman: Legacy. She’s a perfect choice for this character, deserved an opportunity like this & thankfully it happened! I’m so happy for her & she’s gonna do an incredible job https://t.co/oM4Q4QU9ob
— Christian Cortave (@CCortave24) June 27, 2023
PITCH PERFECT LOIS LANE. pic.twitter.com/cTKE80V3tH
— Jimmy Palmiotti (@jpalmiotti) June 27, 2023
With the casting for Superman and Lois Lane out of the way – the next round of auditions for Legacy is expected to screen test actors for Lex Luthor, The Authority characters and Jimmy Olsen to name a few. There were rumors that Supes nemesis – Brainiac would be the threat in DCU’s first film though it remains to be seen and may be addressed by the end of the casting process.
Superman: Legacy will fly into theaters on July 11, 2025.